设为首页 收藏本站
查看: 554|回复: 0

[经验分享] Apache CXF vs. Apache AXIS vs. Spring WS

[复制链接]

尚未签到

发表于 2016-12-31 09:59:43 | 显示全部楼层 |阅读模式
  http://architects.dzone.com/articles/apache-cxf-vs-apache-axis-vs (05.08.2013)
  This blog does not try to compare all available Web Services Development Frameworks but focuses only on three popular approaches regarding three Open Source frameworks: Apache CXF, Apache AXIS & Spring WS.


Let's look at positives & concerns in nutshell of each of these frameworks:

Framework
Key Positives
Key Concerns
Apache AXIS2
❶ Most Commonly Used, Matured & Stable Web Services Development Framework
 
❷ Supports Multiple Languages (C++, Java)
 
❸ Supports both Contract-first & Contract-last Approach
 
❹ In context of Orchestration & Web Services Transaction (long-running transactions) it supports wide variety of related WS-* specifications:
WS-Atomic Transaction, WS-Business Activity, WS-Coordination, WS-Eventing, WS-Transfer
Compatible with Spring Framework
❶ Comparatively More Code Required/Generated w.r.t. Spring WS/CXF
 
❷ Is being phased out gradually (mostly by Apache CXF)
 
❸ It is not fully compliant for JAX-WS JAX-RS
Apache CXF
❶ Most widely used Web Services Standard Now; Improvement over AXIS2, which is now gradually being replaced by Apache CXF
 
❷ Intuitive & Easy to Use (less coding required as compared to AXIS2)
 
❸ Clean separation of front-ends, like JAX-WS, from the core code
 
❹ Fully compliant with JAX-WS, JAX-RS & others
 
❺ Best Performance across all available framework with minimum computation overhead
 
❻ Supports wide variety of front-end models
 
❼ Supports both JAX-WS & JAX-RS (for Restful Services)
 
❽ Supports JBI & SDO (not supported in AXIS2)
 
❾ Compatible with Spring Framework
❶ Does not support Orchestration & WS Transactions yet
 
❷ Does not support WSDL 2.0 yet
Spring WS
❶ Best in terms of supporting Contract-first Web Services Development Approach
 
❷ Enforces Standards & Best Practices by Framework Constraints (no way out of it & hence limitation as well)
 
❸ Supports Spring Annotations as well as JAX-WS
 
❹ Least code from developer’s perspective
 
❺ Best Aligned with Spring Technology Stack (also similar architectural stack as Spring MVC) including Spring Security
❶ Least number of WS-* Specifications supported (does not fully compliant with JAX-WS)
 
❷ Spring offers itself as standard & hence other Java-compliant frameworks support better standards support
 
❸ Only support Contract-first Web Services Development Mode


I have carried out further detailed analysis (using a scorecard) to grill these frameworks further & came up with following scorecard:
 
http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-jwbLq6Bx2-8/UYjba7QsZyI/AAAAAAAABF4/uFUzbR5idw0/s400/overall.png
Conclusion


  • Apache AXIS2 is relatively most used framework but Apache CXF scores over other Web Services Framework comparatively considering ease of development, current industry trend, performance, overall scorecard and other features (unless there is Web Services Orchestration support is explicitly needed, which is not required here)
  • Though Spring Core Framework is an established technology, Spring Web Services is still evolving in comparison with Apache CXF and CXF has wider support of standards and proven framework from performance perspective.
  • Hence, Apache CXF is the recommended framework and clearly the most preferred in my opinion.

运维网声明 1、欢迎大家加入本站运维交流群:群②:261659950 群⑤:202807635 群⑦870801961 群⑧679858003
2、本站所有主题由该帖子作者发表,该帖子作者与运维网享有帖子相关版权
3、所有作品的著作权均归原作者享有,请您和我们一样尊重他人的著作权等合法权益。如果您对作品感到满意,请购买正版
4、禁止制作、复制、发布和传播具有反动、淫秽、色情、暴力、凶杀等内容的信息,一经发现立即删除。若您因此触犯法律,一切后果自负,我们对此不承担任何责任
5、所有资源均系网友上传或者通过网络收集,我们仅提供一个展示、介绍、观摩学习的平台,我们不对其内容的准确性、可靠性、正当性、安全性、合法性等负责,亦不承担任何法律责任
6、所有作品仅供您个人学习、研究或欣赏,不得用于商业或者其他用途,否则,一切后果均由您自己承担,我们对此不承担任何法律责任
7、如涉及侵犯版权等问题,请您及时通知我们,我们将立即采取措施予以解决
8、联系人Email:admin@iyunv.com 网址:www.yunweiku.com

所有资源均系网友上传或者通过网络收集,我们仅提供一个展示、介绍、观摩学习的平台,我们不对其承担任何法律责任,如涉及侵犯版权等问题,请您及时通知我们,我们将立即处理,联系人Email:kefu@iyunv.com,QQ:1061981298 本贴地址:https://www.yunweiku.com/thread-321894-1-1.html 上篇帖子: [Apache] Check the "/xampp/apache/logs/error.log" file 下篇帖子: apxs
您需要登录后才可以回帖 登录 | 立即注册

本版积分规则

扫码加入运维网微信交流群X

扫码加入运维网微信交流群

扫描二维码加入运维网微信交流群,最新一手资源尽在官方微信交流群!快快加入我们吧...

扫描微信二维码查看详情

客服E-mail:kefu@iyunv.com 客服QQ:1061981298


QQ群⑦:运维网交流群⑦ QQ群⑧:运维网交流群⑧ k8s群:运维网kubernetes交流群


提醒:禁止发布任何违反国家法律、法规的言论与图片等内容;本站内容均来自个人观点与网络等信息,非本站认同之观点.


本站大部分资源是网友从网上搜集分享而来,其版权均归原作者及其网站所有,我们尊重他人的合法权益,如有内容侵犯您的合法权益,请及时与我们联系进行核实删除!



合作伙伴: 青云cloud

快速回复 返回顶部 返回列表